Common law contract | UCC contract | |
Scope | Real property Intsngible property Personal property | Sales of goods |
Parties | Between merchants Not between merchants | |
Open terms | Not aloowed | Allowed except open quantity.But this is contingent on seller. |
Option | Yes | Yes |
Firm Offer | By a merchant in a signed writing | |
Mirror image rule | Unequivocal & unconditional | Aditional terms are OK.Prompt promise is OK.Nonconforming goods are OK. |
Mail box rule | Unauthorized means Not the same means Offer said "Acceptance is effective when received". | Offer said "Acceptance is effective when received". |
Modification | Need Consideration | No Consideration |
Statute of Frauds | Real propertyy Surety More than 1 year | Goods more than $500 |
Open terms | Gap filling rule |
Open price | Reasonable price |
Open delivery place | seller's place of business |
Open time for shipment or delivery | Reasonable time |
Open time for payment | At the time & place on delivery |
Open quantuty | Not allowed Except:Output contract(UCC 2-306)&Requirement contract(UCC 2-306) |
Option contract | Firm offer | |
Common law | Yes | No |
UCC | Yes | Yes |
Offeror | Anybody | Merchant |
Must be signed in writing | No | Yes |
Consideration | Reqired | Not reqired |
Rejection by offeree | Not terminating offer | Terminating offer |
The buyer may not inspect the goods before paying for them.
if the goods are purchased for use by the buyer
if the goods are purchased for resale by the buyer
Title & ROL | ||||
after delivery | acceptance | rejection by buyer | ||
Title & ROL | cost of rejection | |||
Sales on approval | Seller | Buyer | Seller | Seller |
Sales or Return | Buyer | Buyer | Buyer | Buyer |
insurable interest ==>buyer & seller
Special property=right to recover=The buyer may recover goods identified to the contract if he/she has paid part of their prices and the seller becomes insolvent within 10 days after receiving the first payment(UCC 2-502).
delivery terms | title passes to buyer | ROL passes to buyer | |
warehouse(without moving) | No W/R | at time of contract | at time of contract |
W/R | upon delivery of W/R | upon delivery of W/R | |
shipping contract FOB shipping point,Ex-ship/COD/No arrival,no sale | upon delivery to destination point | upon delivery to destination point | |
No delivery terms | Merchant | Buyer's place | upon receipt by buyer |
Nonmerchant | Seller's place | upon tender of delivery |
Under shipment contract,ROL remains on seller in one of the below conditions.
If contract provides no provision,open time for payment is applied.
Type | Creation | Seller action | applies to seller of | exception |
Warranty of title
| automatic | No | Merchant&Nonmerchant | |
warranty against infringement | automatic | No | Merchant | Buyer's spec. |
Express warranty | basis of bargain such as
| Yes | Merchant&Nonmerchant | |
Implied warranty of merchantability | automatic | No | Merchant | |
Implied warranty for fitness of particular purpose | Creating on contract
| Yes | Merchant&Nonmerchant | Buyer's spec. |
withholding delivery | stopping | reclaiming goods | |
Rejection | |||
Revocation | |||
Repudation | X | X | |
Tender of payment | X | ||
Buyer's insolvency | X | X |
Privity | Negligence | Plaintiff must proof | Defendant's defence | ||
Negligence | No | Yes | Breach of due care Damages Cause in fact | Contributory negligence | Comparative negligence Assumption of risk |
Strict liabilities | No | No | defective product Unreasonably dangerous Damages Defect causes damages | Assumption of risk Misuse |